The Operation of Markets and Market Failure · 7135/1

AQA AS Paper 1, June 2023

All 12 written questions and 20 multiple choice questions from AQA AS Paper 1 (June 2023), The Operation of Markets and Market Failure. Case studies: Oil and Drones. Each question shows its marks and topic, with an examiner insight on 4, and opens the question paper and mark scheme at the right page.

Context 1

Oil

Extracts: Brent crude oil prices, 2013–2020 and market shares of · The market for oil · Failures in the oil market

Q25Explain10 marks
Extract C (lines 13–14) states: ‘Concerns about the impact of oil on the environment have led to the encouragement of renewable energy, such as solar, wind and tidal power’.
Explain how the development of renewable sources of energy is likely to affect the market for oil.

TopicPrice determination in a competitive marketDemand & supplyCross elasticityCommodity markets

Examiner insight

What to cover
Renewable energy is a substitute for oil, so demand for oil falls and its price falls.
Diagram
Oil market with demand shifting left.
Watch out
Explain substitutes clearly.
Q26Evaluate25 marks
Extract C (lines 20–21) states: ‘Unstable prices, monopoly power, environmental concerns and a vital resource – should governments intervene more in the oil industry?’
Use the extracts and your knowledge of economics to evaluate ways in which governments could deal with the market failures in the oil industry.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionMarket failure (general)Government intervention (micro)

Examiner insight

What to cover
Oil market failures: monopoly power (OPEC), external costs, price volatility and a finite resource.
Diagram
Negative externality diagram.
Evaluation
Policies: carbon taxes, regulation, subsidies for renewables, buffer stocks. Judge by cost and effectiveness.
Watch out
Use the extracts.

Context 2

Drones

Extracts: Annual worldwide sales of commercial drones, 2016–2023 · The rise of the drone · Opportunity or threat?

Q28Calculate4 marks
Extract F (lines 10–12) states: ‘The total cost of a delivery consists of £150 for the drone and another £350 to carry out the whole operation. The drone carries food weighing 110 pounds (50 kilos), enough for 50 people for a day.’
Calculate the average total cost of delivering food weighing one pound. Give your answer to the nearest penny.

TopicProduction, costs and revenueCosts & economies of scale

Q31Explain10 marks
Extract E (lines 8–9) states: ‘Drones can reach remote areas quickly and easily, saving on labour and other costs.’
Explain how the increasing use of drones is likely to affect the market for delivery workers.

TopicThe labour marketLabour demand & supplyTechnological change

Examiner insight

What to cover
Drones replace delivery workers, so demand for delivery workers falls, and wages and employment fall.
Diagram
Labour market with demand shifting left.
Watch out
Explain derived demand.
Q32Assess25 marks
Extract F (lines 23–24) states: ‘if drones become more common, another review may be needed of what is best for all’.
Use the extracts and your knowledge of economics to assess whether governments should encourage, discourage or do nothing more to affect the use of drones.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionExternalitiesGovernment intervention (micro)

Examiner insight

What to cover
Drones bring lower costs and faster delivery, but external costs (noise, safety, privacy).
Diagram
Negative externality diagram.
Evaluation
Judge between encourage, discourage or do nothing.
Watch out
Consider all three options.
Q31 mark
Figure 1 shows the demand (D) and supply (S) curves for scooters.
Market equilibrium is initially at E, the intersection of D1 and S1.
Figure 1
The government announces a cut in the indirect tax on scooters and an increase in the indirect tax on bicycles, a substitute for scooters.
Which one of the following is most likely to be the new equilibrium in the market for scooters?
  1. AF
  2. BG
  3. CH
  4. DI
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionIndirect taxes & subsidiesCross elasticity

Q41 mark
A soap manufacturer experiences a fall in long-run average costs. This is most likely to be the result of
  1. Afewer external economies of scale.
  2. Blower labour productivity.
  3. Copportunities for internal economies of scale.
  4. Dtotal costs increasing by more than output.
Show the answer

The answer is C.

TopicProduction, costs and revenueCosts & economies of scale

Q51 mark
A government decides that visitor centres in nature reserves are merit goods and therefore increases their provision.
It can be concluded that this decision
  1. Aavoided government failure.
  2. Bdid not have an opportunity cost.
  3. Censured provision of a public good.
  4. Dinvolved a normative judgement.
Show the answer

The answer is D.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionMerit & demerit goodsPositive & normative

Q61 mark
The median income is higher in country W than in country Z.
It can be concluded that
  1. Aincomes are more equitably distributed in country W than in country Z.
  2. Bincomes are more unequally distributed in country Z than in country W.
  3. Cthe mean income may be higher or lower in country Z compared with country W.
  4. Dthe ratio of the highest to lowest income is greater in country W than in country Z.
Show the answer

The answer is C.

TopicDistribution of income and wealthInequality & poverty

Q111 mark
Figure 3 shows a supply curve (S) for an industry.
Figure 3
All other things being equal, which one of the following causes the upward slope of the supply curve?
  1. AAn increase in monopoly power at higher levels of output
  2. BFirms achieving economies of scale as output increases
  3. CHigher prices causing firms to improve productive efficiency
  4. DHigher profits providing an incentive to increase output
Show the answer

The answer is D.

TopicPrice determination in a competitive marketDemand & supply

Q121 mark
Table 1 shows the market shares of supermarkets in an economy in 2020.
Table 1
Company % share of market Fresh Co Food Co Value Co Other companies In 2021, Value Co fails to make any profits and decides to leave the market.
The most likely result is that the
  1. Amarket becomes more competitive.
  2. Bmonopoly power of Fresh Co increases.
  3. Cother companies’ market share rises to 37%.
  4. Dtwo-firm concentration ratio becomes 63%.
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicMarket structuresOligopoly

Q131 mark
Hedges around fields encourage wildlife and bring widespread benefits but many farmers choose to have wire fences instead.
Which one of the following best describes the resulting failure in the market for hedges?
  1. AThe social optimum output is greater than the free market output because the private benefit is greater than the social benefit.
  2. BThe social optimum output is greater than the free market output because the private benefit is less than the social benefit.
  3. CThe social optimum output is less than the free market output because the private benefit is greater than the social benefit.
  4. DThe social optimum output is less than the free market output because the private benefit is less than the social benefit.
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionExternalities

Q151 mark
A government sets a maximum price for fruit below the market price to try to encourage healthier eating.
All other things being equal, which one of the following will result in the lowest amount of excess demand for fruit at the maximum price?
  1. ADemand is income elastic and supply is price elastic.
  2. BDemand is income inelastic and supply is price inelastic.
  3. CDemand is price elastic and supply is price elastic.
  4. DDemand is price inelastic and supply is price inelastic.
Show the answer

The answer is D.

TopicPrice determination in a competitive marketDemand & supplyPrice controls

Q161 mark
Healthcare in the UK is provided by the public sector and by private firms. Public sector provision ensures that healthcare is free at the point of consumption for individuals without private health insurance and for those unable to pay for healthcare.
Which one of the following can be concluded about healthcare in the UK?
  1. AHealthcare has the characteristics of a private and public good.
  2. BProduction of healthcare addresses the basic economic questions of ‘how’ and ‘for whom’.
  3. CProvision of healthcare is equitable.
  4. DThe supply of healthcare achieves productive efficiency.
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionMerit & demerit goodsPublic goods

Q171 mark
Figure 4 shows the free market demand (D1) and supply (S) curves for a merit good. D2 is the demand curve if all the benefits from consuming the good are taken into account.
Figure 4
Which one of the following government policies would be most likely to achieve the socially optimal level of consumption?
  1. AA maximum price of P3
  2. BA minimum price of P2
  3. CA subsidy of P1 minus P3 per unit
  4. DA subsidy of P2 minus P3 per unit
Show the answer

The answer is D.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionMerit & demerit goodsIndirect taxes & subsidies

Q191 mark
Figure 5 shows the production possibility curve for an economy producing boots and bicycles. The initial combination of boots and bicycles produced is shown by point E.
Figure 5
A change in consumer preferences causes the boot industry to contract and the bicycle industry to expand.
If labour is not fully mobile between the two industries, then the new combination of boots and bicycles produced is most likely to be at
  1. Apoint F.
  2. Bpoint G.
  3. Cpoint H.
  4. Dpoint I.
Show the answer

The answer is C.

TopicEconomic methodology and the economic problemPPB / PPC

Q201 mark
Which one of the following characteristics of firms can be used to distinguish between market structures?
  1. AFirms’ productivity and total costs
  2. BThe amount that firms choose to produce
  3. CThe extent to which firms differentiate their products
  4. DThe type of technology used by firms 20
Show the answer

The answer is C.

TopicMarket structuresContestability & barriers

Question text is quoted from the question papers, © AQA, for students’ private study. Open the official papers and mark schemes from the links on each question. Examiner insights are written with AI assistance and moderated by Finn.