The Operation of Markets and Market Failure · 7135/1

AQA AS Paper 1, June 2016

All 12 written questions and 20 multiple choice questions from AQA AS Paper 1 (June 2016), The Operation of Markets and Market Failure. Case studies: The UK housing market and The costs of smoking. Each question shows its marks and topic, with an examiner insight on 4, and opens the question paper and mark scheme at the right page.

Context 1

The UK housing market

Extracts: New houses built per year, UK, 1992 to 2013 · A market working well? · Or a market failing?

Q25Explain10 marks
Extract B (lines 10 and 11) states ‘However, the housing market is not a perfectly competitive market.’
Explain why the housing market is not a perfectly competitive market.

TopicMarket structuresPerfect competition

Examiner insight

What to cover
Perfect competition needs many buyers and sellers, identical products, perfect information and free entry. Housing fails these: every home is different, information is imperfect, entry is limited by land and planning, and transaction costs are high.
Watch out
Compare the housing market with each condition of perfect competition.
Q26Assess25 marks
Extract C (lines 20 and 21) states ‘Some are mindful of government failure and advocate a lesser role for governments.’
Use the extracts and your knowledge of economics to assess the view that housing markets should be left to market forces with only the minimum of intervention from governments.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionGovernment failure

Examiner insight

What to cover
Market forces signal where housing is needed and give builders an incentive to supply.
Diagram
Housing market with inelastic supply.
Evaluation
Housing is a merit good with external benefits; homelessness and inequality are market failures. Government failure is possible. Judge using the data on house building.
Watch out
Use the extracts on government failure and homelessness.

Context 2

The costs of smoking

Extracts: Price and quantity of cigarettes consumed in the UK, · Smoking and pregnancy · How should governments deal with smokers?

Q30Draw4 marks
Extract E (lines 10–11) states ‘Researchers at the Universities of Glasgow and Stirling offered pregnant smokers up to £400 worth of shopping vouchers to give up smoking ...’
Draw a diagram to show the effect on the market for cigarettes of giving shopping vouchers to pregnant women as an incentive to stop smoking.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionMerit & demerit goodsDemand & supply

Q31Explain10 marks
Extract F (line 10) states ‘Taxation is one way governments attempt to control cigarette consumption.’
Explain the effect of indirect taxation on the consumption of cigarettes.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionIndirect taxes & subsidies

Examiner insight

What to cover
An indirect tax raises the price of cigarettes. Because demand is price inelastic (addiction, few substitutes), consumption falls only a little and tax revenue is high.
Diagram
Tax diagram with inelastic demand, showing the small fall in quantity.
Watch out
Use price elasticity of demand.
Q32Assess25 marks
Extract F (line 12) states ‘Regulation to reduce consumption of cigarettes is extensive in the UK.’
Use the extracts and your economic knowledge to assess the view that regulation is the best way of dealing with the market failure that results from the consumption of cigarettes.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionGovernment intervention (micro)Merit & demerit goods

Examiner insight

What to cover
Regulation: bans on advertising, plain packaging, smoking bans in public places, age limits.
Diagram
Demerit good diagram.
Evaluation
Compare with taxes and education. Consider enforcement cost, black markets and civil liberties. Judge using the data.
Watch out
Compare regulation with at least one other policy.
Q11 mark
In a free market economy, the economic problem of what goods should be produced is usually solved by
  1. Aconsumers expressing their tastes and preferences in their pattern of spending.
  2. Bhouseholds completing business surveys to reveal their preferred products.
  3. Cfirms planning their activities to meet production targets set by government.
  4. Dentrepreneurs producing their own goods to satisfy their own needs and wants.
Show the answer

The answer is A.

TopicEconomic methodology and the economic problemEconomic systems

Q21 mark
The diagram below shows a production possibility boundary for an economy that produces goods and services.
From the diagram it can be concluded that
  1. Apoint X is productively efficient and point Y is allocatively efficient.
  2. Bpoint Y is productively efficient and point X is allocatively efficient.
  3. Cpoints X and Y are allocatively efficient.
  4. Dpoints X and Y are productively efficient.
Show the answer

The answer is D.

TopicEconomic methodology and the economic problemPPB / PPC

Q41 mark
Monopoly can provide an example of market failure because firms with monopoly power
  1. Amay produce a larger output than would be supplied in a competitive market so that they achieve economies of scale.
  2. Bmay produce a lower output, less efficiently, than would be supplied by a competitive market.
  3. Calways charge high prices and earn high profits.
  4. Dhave no incentive to meet consumer demands.
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicMarket structuresMonopoly & market powerMarket failure (general)

Q61 mark
Many agricultural products are subject to large fluctuations in price. One reason why these large fluctuations occur is because the
  1. Ademand for agricultural products is income inelastic in the long run.
  2. Bsupply of agricultural products is price elastic in the long run.
  3. Csupply of agricultural products is price inelastic in the short run.
  4. Ddemand for agricultural products is price elastic in the short run.
Show the answer

The answer is C.

TopicPrice determination in a competitive marketCommodity markets

Q71 mark
A good has a price elasticity of supply of +0.8. At present, the quantity supplied of the good is 200 units per week at a market price of £800 per unit. If the price rises to £1000 per unit then the quantity supplied per week would
  1. Aincrease to 250 units.
  2. Bincrease to 240 units.
  3. Cincrease to 360 units.
  4. Ddecrease to 160 units.
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicPrice determination in a competitive marketPrice elasticity of supply

Q81 mark
A reduction in the market price of a firm’s product will always result in an increase in its profits or a reduction in its losses if it
  1. Aincreases its share of the market.
  2. Bincreases its total revenue by more than its total costs.
  3. Cenables it to reduce its average costs.
  4. Dleads to a reduction in the price of its inputs.
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicProduction, costs and revenueRevenue & profitPrice elasticity of demand

Q91 mark
The diagram below shows a firm’s average total cost curve (ATC), with the firm producing an output of OX.
The firm’s productive efficiency will improve if the
  1. AATC curve shifts upwards for any given level of output.
  2. BATC curve shifts downwards for any given level of output.
  3. Cfirm increases its level of output.
  4. Dfirm reduces its level of output.
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicProduction, costs and revenueProductivity & efficiency

Q101 mark
All other things being equal, which one of the following situations always results in a rise in labour productivity?
  1. AOutput falls at a slower rate than the fall in the number of workers employed
  2. BOutput falls at a faster rate than the fall in the number of workers employed
  3. COutput rises at a slower rate than the rise in the number of workers employed
  4. DOutput always rises as the number of workers employed increases
Show the answer

The answer is A.

TopicProduction, costs and revenueProductivity & efficiency

Q111 mark
Which one of the following is the best indicator of the degree of competition in an industry?
  1. AThe industry’s concentration ratio
  2. BThe elasticity of supply of the industry’s output
  3. CThe number of workers employed in the industry
  4. DThe total value of the industry’s sales
Show the answer

The answer is A.

TopicMarket structuresOligopoly

Q121 mark
The table below shows the characteristics of four private sector firms. Which one of the firms, A, B, C or D, is most likely to be in a competitive market?
Barriers to Firm Profit entry
  1. AA Low High
  2. BB Low Low
  3. CC High High
  4. DD High Low
Show the answer

The answer is B.

TopicMarket structuresContestability & barriersPerfect competition

Q131 mark
The diagrams below show four possible long run average cost curves (LRAC) for a firm operating in a market where the annual sales are 400 000 units per year.
All other things being equal, which one of the cost curves, A, B, C or D, is most likely to enable the firm to achieve monopoly power in the market for its product?
  1. A(see diagram in paper)
  2. B(see diagram in paper)
  3. C(see diagram in paper)
  4. D(see diagram in paper)
Show the answer

The answer is C.

TopicProduction, costs and revenueCosts & economies of scaleMonopoly & market power

Q141 mark
An essential characteristic of a public good is that it is non-excludable. This means that
  1. Apublic goods are of equal benefit to all consumers.
  2. Bthere is no opportunity cost in the provision of public goods.
  3. Cpeople could consume the good without paying for it.
  4. Dthe government should not levy a tax for providing public goods.
Show the answer

The answer is C.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionPublic goods

Q161 mark
The diagram below illustrates a market in which a monopolist takes control and sets a price above the competitive level.
The price charged by the monopolist is OS. If the market had been competitive, the price would have been OR. Under monopoly, the amount buyers spend on the product has increased by
  1. ARSTY.
  2. BOS multiplied by OW.
  3. CRSTU.
  4. DRSTY minus WYUV.
Show the answer

The answer is D.

TopicMarket structuresMonopoly & market power

Q181 mark
The diagram below shows the market demand curve (D) and two market supply (S1 and S2) curves for a good. The initial equilibrium point is at E1. The introduction by the government of an indirect tax per unit of the good results in a new equilibrium at E2.
The amount of the indirect tax per unit is measured by the
  1. Avertical distance FE2.
  2. Bincrease in price P1P2.
  3. Cthe diagonal distance E1E2.
  4. Dthe horizontal distance GE1.
Show the answer

The answer is A.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionIndirect taxes & subsidies

Q191 mark
The diagram below shows the demand and supply curves for a good provided solely by a free market.
Currently, output is at OQ1. However, there is a misallocation of resources resulting in market failure. The socially optimal level of production is OQ2. Which one of the following statements is correct? The diagram shows the market for
  1. Aa merit good.
  2. Ba public good.
  3. Ca good with negative externalities in production.
  4. Da good with positive externalities in production.
Show the answer

The answer is C.

TopicMarket failure and government interventionExternalitiesMerit & demerit goods

Q201 mark
Which one of the following statements about the distribution of income must be correct?
  1. AThe distribution of income is equitable when everyone has the same income
  2. B‘The distribution of income is equitable’ is a positive statement
  3. CAn unequal distribution of income is, by definition, inequitable
  4. DWhether the distribution of income is equitable depends on a value judgement
Show the answer

The answer is D.

TopicDistribution of income and wealthInequality & poverty

Question text is quoted from the question papers, © AQA, for students’ private study. Open the official papers and mark schemes from the links on each question. Examiner insights are written with AI assistance and moderated by Finn.